Himalayan Journal vol.36
The Himalayan Journal
Vol.36

Publication year:
1980

Editor:
Harish Kapadia
Index
  1. EDITORIAL
  2. KANGCHENJUNGA
    (COL. N. KUMAR)
  3. KANGCHENJUNGA SOUTH AND CENTRAL
    (MAREK MALATYNSKI and PIOTR MLOTECKI)
  4. THE BRITISH KANGCHENJUNGA EXPEDITION 1979
    (DOUG SCOTT)
  5. JANNU -ALPINE STYLE
    (RAB CARRINGTON)
  6. INTERNATIONAL MAKALU EXPEDITION 1978
    (DR HERMANN WARTH)
  7. THE GERMAN-FRENCH MOUNT EVEREST EXPEDITION, 1978
    (DR K. M. HERRLIGKOFFER)
  8. ON SHERPA TRAIL
    (HARISH KAPADIA)
  9. HIMALCHULI '78
    (JOHN CLEARE)
  10. SOUTH PILLAR OF DHAULAGIRI I
    (TAKASHI AMEMIYA)
  11. NANDA NORTH FACE
    (TERRY KING)
  12. NANDA DEVI -VIA THE SOUTH RIDGE
    (MICHAEL CLARKE)
  13. TWENTY-EIGHT DAYS OF TRISUL
    (SADASHIGE INADA)
  14. BALLAD OF BETHARTOLI
    (JOHN NANSON)
  15. MOUNTAIN OF LONG LIFE
    (HARISH KAPADIA)
  16. PLEISTOCENE GLACIATION IN THE SHANKALPA DIVIDE
    (M. K. BANDYOPADHYAY)
  17. KEDARNATH MASSIF
    (SQN LDR V. P. SINGH)
  18. A HIMALAYAN ADVENTURE: JAONLI
    (LT COL. D. K. KHULLAR)
  19. BANDARPUNCH AND HANUMAN CLIMBED 1978
    (PARASH MONI DAS)
  20. PHAWARARANG -AN ASCENT IN KINNAUR
    (BALWANT SANDHU)
  21. MINAR AND M6
    (SQN LDR E. J. M. THOMAS)
  22. YOUTH COMES FIRST IN THE HIMALAYA
    (DAVID H. CHALLIS)
  23. BRAMMAH I
    (ANTHONY WHEATON)
  24. SIXTH ASCENT OF KUN (7087 m)
    (ROBERT SCHAUER)
  25. THE WORK OF ITALIANS IN THE SCIENTIFIC EXPLORATION OF THE KARAKORAM (CENTRAL ASIA)
    (ARDITO DESIO)
  26. K2 : THE AMERICAN ASCENT
    (JAMES WICKWIRE)
  27. NOSHAQ - A ROUTE OFF THE BEATEN TRACK
    (H. C. ENGELE)
  28. A TRIP FROM USHU TO CHITRAL
    (ARMIN BEER, ERWIN LANG and HELMUT HESSE)
  29. THREE PIONEERS: THE SCHLAGINT- WEIT BROTHERS
    (HELGA ALCOCK)
  30. SOME THOUGHTS ON THE EXPEDITION CLIMBING GAME
    (DAVID HOPKINS)
  31. MOUNTAINEERING -A VITAL SOURCE OF INSPIRATION AND GUIDANCE
    (REIN HARD SANDERS)
  32. SMALL EXPEDITIONS IN THE HIMALAYA
    (ROB COLLISTER)
  33. EXPEDITIONS AND NOTES
  34. THE EIGHT-THOUSANDERS
  35. EXPEDITIONS 1976-1979
  36. IN MEMORIUM
  37. BOOK REVIEWS
  38. CORRESPONDENCE
  39. CLUB PROCEEDINGS, 1978

INTERNATIONAL MAKALU EXPEDITION 1978

DR HERMANN WARTH

PROGRESS : On 11 March 1978 flight from Kathmandu to T'umlingtar in Eastern Nepal. March in with 110 porters and 3.3 tons luggage via Khandbari, Num, Ala till Bungim (4 days). In Bungim-the last inhabited village-change of porters is necessary because the hill porters are not used to carrying loads at the higher altitude; the Kongma La, a pass more than 4100 m high has to be surmounted. Bad weather and unusually heavy snow (2-3 m) caused 55 porters to turn back. In a kind of relay system the loads had been brought over the pass from Bungim to Pematak within 7 days. The members of the expedition also carried loads. We equipped the porters with sun-glasses, blankets and shoes. Their performance in the face of extremely bad conditions deserves utmost appreciation. According to their information no Makalu expedition had had to tackle such bad weather conditions on the Kongma La. In Pematak 40 more porters returned because they had run out of food. The remaining 15, we fed out of our own stock. Also in the Barun valley towards Ribuk and the Base Camp there were immense masses of snow, that required unusual efforts to break the trail. On 29 March a group of trail-breakers (Ang Chappal, H. v. Kaenel, H. Warth) reached the Base Camp after 8 hours' hard work from Ribuk. Base Camp was established on 31 March by H. v. Kaenel, K. Diemberger, Sherap and H. Warth. It was the 20th day after our departure from Tumlingtar!

It was another week before all loads had arrived at the Base Camp and we used the time for exploration. In view of the loss of valuable time during the approach march and the dangerous-looking serac zones of the icefall on the SE. we decided to attempt the ascent on the NW. side which was more or less the route of the French expedition of 1955" led by Jean Franco which succeeded in the first climb of Makalu. Since then, no team had succeeded in climbing the mountain by this route.

On 3 April, K. Diemberger and H. v. Kaenel found the place for Advanced Base Camp (ABC), which was established on 4 April by Nga Temba, Nawang Tensing and H. Warth. The next day they found the route to the upper Chago glacier where On 11, 12 and 13 April, Ang Chappal and H. Warth provided the partially difficult route to the so-called ice balcony with about 300 m fixed rope and pitched Camp 2 on 13 April at 7000 m height. In the following days the weather was not too good. Therefore, K. Diemberger, H. v. Kaenel, Nawang Tensing and Nga Temba could not reach the Col ('Makalu La'). The days had been used for extensive ferries to Camps 1 and 2. After long and difficult climbing and fixing ropes (300 m) on the steep rocks leading to the Col by H. v. Kaenel, K. Diemberger, Nawang Tensing, Nga Temba, Ang Chappal and H. Warth, these latter . two and K. Diemberger succeeded in establishing Camp 3 on the Col at a height of 7410 m on 24 April. This completed the first part of the route.

Photo Plates 18-22

H.V. Kaenel and Nga Temba explored the further route towards Camp 4. After four nights above 7000 m they descended with slight health deficiencies to Camp 1 for a longer rest. It is now the turn of Nawang Tensing and K. Diemberger who carry oxygen bottles to a depot between Camp 3 and the forthcoming Camp 4 and who are going to stay for a longer time in Camp 3 in order to give eventually necessary help to the summit team.

On 29 April Ang Chappal and H. Warth climbed from Camp 2 to Camp 3. Supported by Nawang Tensing (trail-breaking, carrying load) they reached on 30 April the place for Camp 4 at 7950 m. They slept there without using oxygen. Nawang Tensing descended to Camp 3 on the Col. On 1 May, at 7 a.m. Ang Chappal and H. Warth started for the summit. Since Ang Chappal felt uncomfortable wearing the oxygen mask and breathing through it he decided in Camp 4 to try the climb without the help of artificial oxygen. Therefore, H. Warth had to break the trail on the whole route which was very strenuous on the vast snow-slopes. With nearly each step he was breaking in up to his thighs and his hips. This effort was only possible by higher rate of oxygen support (3 and 4). At 8250 m they reached the 45°-50° steep and about 200 m high couloir leading to the upper part of the E. ridge. The snow conditions in the couloir were even worse. A difficult rock barrier had to be climbed and prepared for the descent and upcoming parties by a 50 m long rope. Finally, at 1.30 p.m. the two climbers stood on the very sharp snow ridge leading to the two summits of Makalu. Carefully belaying each other they had to climb over some sections as steep as 70° to the very small main peak, which they reached at 2.45 p.m. (8481 m). An old yellow oxygen bottle proves a former victory. The view towards North (Kang- chungtse, Chomo Lonzo, Tibet) and South (Base Camp, ABC, Chamlang, Hongu mountains) was excellent. In the West and East clouds prevented views towards Everest, Lhotse and Kangchenjunga. There was nearly no wind at the summit, which enabled the two to stand 45 minutes on it (Or rather round the summit because it is extremely sharp). At 6 p.m. they arrived without accident in Camp 4. The effort of Ang Chappal is especially worthy of mention : without artificial oxygen he had reached the proud summit of Makalu after carrying heavy loads and only three days' rest since our departure from Tumlingtar. The next day the two climbers met in Camp 3, Dr K. Landvogt and not as they had expected K. Diemberger and Nawang

Tensing. Both of them had had to descend to ABC, K. Diemberger later even to the forests at 3700 m because of throat inflammation and high-altitude cough.

On 3 and 4 May, H. v. Kaenel, K. Landvogt and Nga Temba prepared a further attempt for the summit. But bad weather and high-altitude troubles of K. Landvogt and Nga Temba forced them to return to Camp 1. Together with Ang Chappal they climbed again on 8 May to the Col. On 9 May they reached Camp 4. On the same day Nawang Tensing and H. Warth climbed to Camp 3 as a support team and in order to maintain walkie-talkie communication between Camp 4 and the lower camps. On 10 May in the morning there is no communication with Camp 4. Nawang Tensing and H. Warth cannot leave the tent because it is a stormy day. Towards 6 p.m. the sky becomes clear. To their utmost astonishment they can recognize 3 spots on the top of Makalu: H. v. Kaenel, Nga Temba and K. Landvogt. They didn't reach Camp 4 on the same day, where Ang Chappal was waiting for them, but had a very cold bivouac at the height of 8250 m. Bad weather and defects of the oxygen sets were the reasons for the loss of time. They arrived at Camp 4 on 11 May in the morning. Ang Chappal and Nga Temba descended to Camp 3 which has been informed by walkie-talkie communication from Camp 4 that H. v. Kaenel and K. Landvogt are in good condition and will come on the same day to Camp 3 after a few hours' rest in Camp 4, whereas Ang Chappal and Nga Temba will descend to Camp 1. After this reassuring message Nawang Tensing and H. Warth left Camp 3 and returned to Camp 1. But the evening walkie-talkie communication reported that Ang Chappal and Nga Temba were staying in Camp 3 and H. v. Kaenel and K. Landvogt still in Camp 4 at the great height of 7950 m. The next day, therefore, Nawang Tensing and H. Warth climbed up again the 1200 m from Camp 1 to Camp 3. On the route they met the descending brothers Ang Chdppal and Nga Temba who reported that H. v. Kaenel and K. Landvogt had reached Camp 3 this day but were not willing or able to descend further today. In the afternoon Nawang Tensing and H. Warth met the considerably exhausted H. v. Kaenel and Landvogt. H. v. Kaenel was in addition totally snow-blind. Both had frostbites on hands and feet of 2nd and 3rd grade. Nawang Tensing guided K. Landvogt down to Camp 1 which they reached at 8 p.m. whereas H. Warth did not succeed in bringing down H. v. Kaenel further than Camp 2 (7000 m). The steep slope beneath the Col (40°-50°) required very careful climbing and belaying. On 14 May the whole team was back in the Base Camp, including K. Diemberger who had cured his throat-sickness and his cough in the lower region of forests.

On 17 May Nawang Tensing, K. Diemberger and H. Warth climbed up again for a third summit attempt. They were accompanied by Nga Temba and Ang Chappal. On 20 May they arrived in Camp 4. It was badly damaged by storms and snow- fall and nearly totally buried by now. The next day Nawang Tensing, K. Diemberger and H. Warth left the tents at 6 a.m. Unfortunately only two oxygen sets were working. H. Warth accompanied Nawang Tensing and K. Diemberger till the couloir leading to the ridge. There at 8250 m ..he checked their oxygen sets and connected a new bottle to each and returned to Camp 3. K. Diemberger and Nawang Tensing reached as third team the summit of Makalu at 1 p.m. At 8 p.m. they were back in Camp 3. K. Diemberger was snow-blind and had to be accompanied the next day by H. Warth to Camp 1.

On the same day Ang Chappal, Nga Temba and Nawang Tensing started to clear the camps and to carry down the equipment. On 23 May the whole team was together in the Base Camp. On 25 May the expedition started the march back to Tumlingtar. On 3 June it reached Kathmandu.

Members of the Team : Ang Chappal, Sirdar (Nepal), Kurt Diemberger, Deputy Leader (Austria), Hans von Kaenel (Switzerland), Dr Karl Landvogt, Physician (F.R.G.), Nga Temba (Nepal), Nawang Tensing (Nepal), Dietlinde Warth, Base Camp Manager (F.R.G.), Dr Hermann Warth, Leader (F.R.G.). This was the 7th ascent of Makalu and 2nd by NW. route. Full team of seven reached the summit, including Ang Chappal without oxygen

Chamlang from Camp 1 on Chopo glacier.

Chamlang from Camp 1 on Chopo glacier.



Makalu South Face and West Pillar from Base Camp.

Makalu South Face and West Pillar from Base Camp.



Unclimbed West Face of Makalu from ABC.

Unclimbed West Face of Makalu from ABC.



Camp 3 on Col and last 1000 to top of Makalu.

Camp 3 on Col and last 1000 to top of Makalu.



Lhotse, South Col and Everest from Camp 3. In fore ground Shartse (Junction Peak) and Pethangtse.

Lhotse, South Col and Everest from Camp 3. In fore ground Shartse (Junction Peak) and Pethangtse.