Himalayan Journal vol.34
The Himalayan Journal
Vol.34

Publication year:
1976

Editor:
Soli S. Mehta
Index
  1. EVEREST SOUTH-WEST FACE CLIMBED
    (Doug Scott)
  2. THE FRENCH EXPEDITION TO PUMORI (7,145 m.), 1975
    (Gerard Sighele)
  3. TREKKING IN NEPAL HIMALAYA - LANGTANG VALLEY
    (Rajendra Desai)
  4. DHAULAGIRI II -EAST RIDGE, 1975
    (Yoshio Kameyama)
  5. FIRST ASCENT AND TRAGEDY ON DHAULAGIRI IV, 1975
    (SHIRO NISHAMAE)
  6. TALUNG, 1975
    (A. J. S. GREWAL)
  7. ACCOUNT OF THE EXPLORATION OF TONGSHIONG GLACIER AND THE ZEMU GAP (19,230 ft.)
    (By J. K. BAJAJ)
  8. ACCOUNT OF AN ATTEMPT ON GUICHA PEAK (20,100 ft.)
    (P. C. S. RAUTELA)
  9. PHOKSUMDO LAKE
    (SUMANT SHAH)
  10. NORTH NANDADEVI BASIN AFTER FORTY YEAR
    (KIYOSHI SHIMIZU)
  11. THE ASCENT OF NANDADEVI AND NANDADEVI EAST, 1975
    (BALWANT S. SANDHU)
  12. KALANKA, 1974
    (MIKE TOWNEND)
  13. ASCENTS OF BANDARPUNCH (6,316 M.), 1975
    (L. P. SHARMA)
  14. THE I.M.A. EXPEDITION TO GANG CHUA AND LEO PARGIAL, 1974
    (JAGJIT SINGH)
  15. ACROSS KUGTI AND CHOBIA PASSES
    (K. C. PRASHAR)
  16. ON SKIS ACROSS ROHTHANG
    (RUPENDRA KUMAR SHARMA)
  17. KISHTWAR 1975
    (ROB COLLISTER)
  18. POLISH ASCENTS OF GASHERBRUM II AND III, 1975
    (JANUSZ ONYSZKIEWICZ)
  19. MY ESCAPE FROM GASHERBRUM II
    (LOUIS AUDOUBERT)
  20. VICTORY AND TRAGEDY ON BROAD PEAK, 1975
    (J. FERENSKI and K. GLAZEK)
  21. MOUNTAINS OF THE THUI GOL
    (DAVE BROADHEAD)
  22. SHAKLHAUR, 1975
    (DR. MARIAN BALA)
  23. AVALANCHE SEARCH TODAY
    (WALTER F. LORCH)
  24. EXPERIENCE WITH RESCUE TRANSCEIVERS
    (PETER S. LAWTON)
  25. THE GAURISHANKAR QUESTION
    (OVE SKJERVEN)
  26. BIRDS OF SWAT AND GILGIT
    (R. J. ISHERWOOD)
  27. HEAD INJURIES
    (BRAD FRANCIS)
  28. THE COLDER YOU ARE, THE WARMER YOU'LL BE
    (ELLIS LADER)
  29. THE SECOND SWEDISH EXPEDITION TO THE HIMALAYA, 1975
    (DR. S. UNGERHOLM)
  30. EXPEDITIONS TXIMIST TO EVEREST 1974
    (J. X. LORENTE ZUGUZA)
  31. LHOTSE, 1975
    (RICCARDO CASSIN)
  32. ANNAPURNA SOUTH PEAK-SOUTH-WEST RIDGE, 1974
    (TSUNEO SUZUKI)
  33. CHUREN HIMAL, 1974
    (HIROAKI YAMADA)
  34. TRISUL, 1975
    (MICHAEL CLARKE)
  35. DUNAGIRI, 1975
    (JOE TASKER)
  36. THE SILVER GOD MOUNTAIN (MULKILA) 1975
    (WARWICK DEACOCK)
  37. THE SPANISH EXPEDITION TO MANALI, 1975
    (JAIME MATAS)
  38. BRITISH EXPEDITION TO THE NOSHAQ REGION, 1974
    (ERIC ROBERTS)
  39. THE SPANISH HIMALAYAN EXPEDITION TO SARAGHRAR, 1975
    (RAMON BRAMONA RAMS)
  40. PURWAKSHAN VALLEY HINDU KUSI1. 1975
    (M. POPKO)
  41. THE 1975 NORTH OF ENGLAND HIMALAYA EXPEDITION
    (PAUL BEAN)
  42. OBITUARY
  43. BOOK REVIEWS
  44. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
  45. CLUB PROCEEDINGS 1975

MOUNTAINS OF THE THUI GOL

DAVE BROADHEAD

Edinburgh University Hindu Raj Expedition 1975
Members : Dave Broadhead, Geoff Cohen, Dave Page, George Gibson, Des Rubens.

THE Hindu Raj range lies between the Chitral slopes of the Hindu Kush and the Karakoram, and the upper reaches of the Yarkun and the Indus rivers. As part of the Gilgit Agency, Tom Longstaff first appraised the mountaineering potential while stationed there in 1916-17. "On the northern frontier of Yasin lie some of the finest mountains in the Hindu Kush. To the west are the Thui peaks and to the north the Darkot group; five peaks 'from over 20,000 to over 22,000 feet' (This My Voyage 1950, p. 205). The area was subsequently visited by R. C. F. Schomberg, who introduced the name Hindu Raj (A. J., 251, p. 316). Translated as Hindu Rule, we found this incongruous name offended many Muslims. In Rawalpindi our expedition title, discreetly painted on the door of our van, was daubed over by an indignant Pakistani. In Gilgit and Yasin the area is known simply as Thui.

The Japanese began serious exploration in 1956, and develop¬ments to 1970 are described in detail by Dr. A. Diemberger, tireless collator and willing source of information on the area. (Himalayan Journal, Vol. XXXI, p. 310). The main ridge of high peaks runs north, then takes a sharp turn east, providing the frontier line between Chitral and Kashmir. Access from the Yasin side via Gilgit has previously presented a problem in obtaining permission, with the Pakistan government favouring the longer approach to the northern glaciers via Chitral. Fol¬lowing an extensive reconnaisance in 1987, Dr. Gerald Gruber published fine panoramas of the Thui peaks, taken from the north. (Alpine Journal 316, p. 55.) He described Thui II (6524 m.) as "the most beautiful and isolated summit in the Hindu Kush or Hindu Raj", warning that "the ascent will require a strong team and a massive outlay of equipment." Attracted by such a challenge, in 1969 the British Hindu Raj Expedition led by Dick Isherwood approached Thui II from the north, by way of the Shetor glacier (A.J. 319, p. 179). Attacking the South-east ridge, the onset of bad weather robbed them of success close to the summit. With an easing of political pressures, in 1974 Ron Rutland and a party from the Charlotte Mason College of Education approached Thui II from the south via Yasin and tlx- Thui Gol valley. They established a Base Camp at the foot of the Qualandar Gum glacier, but poor snow conditions pre vented any attempt on the summit. With such a fine objective,, our plans were well under way when we learned of a rival English expedition with a prior claim.

Fortunately we did not have to look for alternatives. To the south Thui II, opposite the Qualandar Gum glacier, stands Thui Zom. (p. 6158 m.). In 1967, a two-man Japanese expedition had camped on the west side of the Thui An pass, and gazed in awe at "the desperate northern side of Thui Zom with its enormous wall, approximately 2000 m. high, at an average angle of 70° with hanging ice blocks here and there". Thus Dr. Diemberger presented their photograph, noting that "it is clear that these savage towers constitute a tremendous problem for the hardiest of climbers". We were bitterly disappointed when our applica¬tion to attempt Thui Zom from the unexplored Ghalsapar glacier was turned down in favour of a large Swiss expedition based at the foot of the Qualandar Gum, below the north face.

Our remaining alternative, obvious from Dr. Gruber's panorama, was Thui I (6662 m.), second highest peak in the area. In 196S the mountain was attempted by the Japanese from a base on the Pechus glacier. Two climbers attempting an unsupported alpine style ascent were not seen again. In 1970, another Japanese attempt, from the Ponarillo glacier, was defeated by bad weather. With permission granted for an attempt on Thui I, we were dis¬appointed to learn from Dr. Diemberger that the peak had been climbed in 1974, by a Japanese party based on the Borum Bar glacier, by the approach we planned. However, using all their time and resources establishing three high camps to conquer this elusive prize, they had not bothered with any of the surrounding peaks.

In 1974 it had been possible to drive a van all the way to Gilgit. The Karakorum Highway is a grandiose scheme to link China and Pakistan and Chinese engineers are currently building a two-lane road across the Himalaya, through Hunza and Gilgit to Islamabad. While they are at work, the Hunza valley and the Gilgit road are forbidden to Westerners; when they finish, Gilgit will be robbed of its remoteness. However in 1975 the area was completely cut off for much of the summer by storm damage to the old road, leaving communications in the hands of Pakistan International Airlines. At the mercy of the weather, irregular flights disrupted the plans of many of the flood of expeditions travelling to Gilgit and Skardu. We were lucky compared with others, and only delayed a total of seven days. Crowded inside a C130 transport, we missed our glimpse of Nanga Parbat, visible only from the other side of the plane, supposedly a highlight of this famous flight.

From Gilgit a precarious jeep track follows the Gilgit River ninety miles north-east to Yasin, the idyllic gateway to Thui and the administrative centre of the area. After the hospitality we received, we got the same impression as Colonel Schomberg, ever forty years ago; "a very smiling country and very decent folk." (Between the Oxus and the Indus, 1935, p. 60.) A few miles further on, near Barendas, a crumbling gorge guards the entrance to the Thui Gol valley. The jeep road continues north lo Darkot, awaiting completion of the suspension bridge over the Thui River, while at last we turned our backs on mechnical transport. Since the deposition of the Rajas in 1970, administration has been in the hands of government agents, known as Tahsildars. Eager to be of every assistance, the Tahsildar of Yasin arranged porters for our walk up the valley. He was enthusiastic about the economic benefits from foreign expeditions to such poor areas; we were surprised to find the standard rate f a porters at 40 rupees (£2) per day, an increase of 150% . In Islamabad too, the Ministry of Tourism regard mountaineeing as a source of foreign exchange. In 1975 they introduced peak royalties, charging us 600 dollars for Thui I. This proved to be the last straw for the team that had between us to Thui II, and they abandoned their plans, too late for us to of¬ficially change our objective.


Arriving a few days behind the mammoth Swiss Thui Expedi¬tion, we barely managed to recruit the twenty-three porters we needed for the four day approach. Passing through a string of small villages, the richly cultivated lower reaches of the Thui Gol gradually gave way to more rugged scenery, enclosed by rocky walls leading up to peaks of 19,000 feet and over. Near the head of the valley, the towering ridges of Thui Zom dominated, with the higher Thui peaks to the north hidden, apart from a tantalising glimpse of Thui II. The Thui An is still used as a pass over to Chitral, though the government apparently disap¬proves of the movement of people and flocks through the mountains. Above Sholtoli, the path leads onto the Aghost Bar glacier, while we turned north and climbed steeply up onto the Borum Bar glacier, establishing Base Camp at about 14,000 feet on the west lateral moraine.

Surrounded by a huge horseshoe of fine unclimbed snow and rock peaks, we could not have hoped for a finer position. Visible from Sholtoli, the south east face of peak 6175 m. dominated the coire, lined with rocky ribs and thin snow couloirs, indicating some hard climbing. The coire headwall, a curtain of steep rock pillars, linked this peak with the forepeak of Thui I (6400 m.), a long hopelessly pinnacled ridge. Crowned with a wedge of snow, the forepeak stood aloof with a majestic air. A long narrow hanging glacier beckoned as the obvious route to our objective, the higher summit (P. 6662 m.), hidden from view. Coming south, a rim of crumbling ice cliffs capped the ridge, rising to the rocky "Twin Peaks" (P. 6100 m. and P. 6200 m.) separated by a steep glacier tongue. Facing their west flanks, the north peak, P. 6100 m., presented a huge black buttress, and the south peak P. 6200 m. a long jagged curving red ridge. Thrusting into the Thui Gol, peaks 5508 m. and 5600 m. had been obvious rock peaks on the walk in, but from Base Camp they were two pleasant looking snow cones, separated by glacier cols to the north.

We began our climbing on 20 July after two days at Base Camp. Des, Dave and myself climbed P. 5600 m. while Geoff and George climbed P. 5508 m., from bivouacs on the respective cols at about 16,000 feet. Straightforward snow plods, climbing became a struggle with the effects of altitude, panting for breath, hearts pounding. Looking from these lower summits to our higher objectives, we realised that we still had a long way to go in getting fit. The view alone made up for the effort. Immediately to the east, towering over the Kerun Bar glacier, two impressive unnamed snow peaks, the higher just over 6000 m., while beyond, the Baltoro group and Chinese Turkestan, a sea of shining white peaks. Three days later, George and Geoff began their campaign arainst P. 6175 m., tentatively named Thui I. 5, or Sholtoli Zom. Gaining the south ridge at about 19,000 feet via an ice couloir, they sat out the heat of the day contemplating the highly crenellated ridge. Faced with pinnacles resembling the Dames Anglaises of the Peuterey Ridge of Mont Blanc, they discreetly retreated.

In preparation for further attempts we established a high camp of two tunnel tents at the head of the BorumBar glacier, at about 16,000 feet, and on 28 July Des joined George and Geoff for another attempt on P. 6175 m. A long thin snow couloir offered the only obvious weakness in the imposing headwall, a straightforward climb by torchlight despite a few rock pitches of grade IV. Above, a steep ridge of hard ice presented serious difficulties. With the summit still some distance away, a deterioration in the weather forced a retreat from a point just above 6000 m., involving an epic bivouac on the steep ridge. Meanwhile, Dave and I had been sitting it out at our High Camp, watching the clouds and idly acclimatising. On 30 July, despite the clouds, we climbed the long steep glacier below the forepeak, intent on Thui I. On the rim of a huge snow bowl, at about 20,000 feet we looked in vain to the summit, covered in cloud. As if by prior arrangement, the wind suddenly changed from south to north, and the clouds cleared. With the setting sun casting a rosy tint on the sea of anonymous peaks stretching before us to Nanga Parbat on the far horizon, we settled down to an airy bivouac.

Setting off well before dawn, with just enough light from a waning moon we traversed below P. 6400 m. Aiming for a broad snow saddle below an intermediate rocky crest hiding the summit, we were going strongly, the rising sun still hidden by Koyo Zom. Suddenly, with a sickening crack, the innocent looking snow slope opened beneath us. Bewildered and battered by falling snow, Dave was swallowed up while I jumped clear, rolling down the slope. In a few moments silence and stillness returned, as the sun at last rose above Koyo Zom. With the taut rope tied off to my ice axe, I crawled anxiously to the edge of the crevasse. A faint voice from the depths informed me that he was hanging undamaged, about forty feet down, still holding his ice axe. Two hours later he emerged, severely chilled, slightly frostbitten and exhausted, after a desperate struggle to prussick up the rope, cut deep in the soft snow. Moving cautiously to the rocky crest, for once we were glad of the burning mid day sun, as Dave gradually warmed up again. Gazing across to Thui II, and beyond the mountains of Afghanistan and Russia, the summit of Thui I seemed so near. Not satisfied with a near miss, as we retraced our steps in the cool of the evening we made an attempt on P. 6400 m. on the way. Climb¬ing by torch light, we were repulsed a few hundred feet from the summit by exhaustion, and windslab snow on hard ice.

In the light of our reconnaissance, for a second attempt on Thui I Des, Geoff and George established a High Camp at our bivouac site at 20,000 feet, and duly climbed P. 6400 m. on 5 Augur.1 Intending to climb the main summit after a rest day, they decided instead to attempt the "Twin Peaks", rather than retracing their steps. A long traverse along the rim of the snow bowl led to P. 6100 m. and thence to P. 6200 m. On the latter summit, an impressive 60 foot rock pinnacle climbed by a pitch of grade IV, they were surprised to find a bird's foot.

To the south, across the valley, we never lost sight of Thui Zom, a useful measuring stick for altitude. Contemplating its improbable northern aspect as we sat out the heat of the day, when climbing was unbearable, we discussed possible lines but it looked so desperate that we gave up thinking about sneaking over and having a crack. No longer envious of the Swiss, we were curious about their progress, so we paid them a visit.' West of P. 6158 m. a long ridge drops down to a low col, the only sign of weakness, guarded by a line of threatening seracs. Hav¬ing tried to reach this "Col of Despair" they produced an impressive collection of broken karabiners and bent pitons, grim souvenirs. Frightened off Thui Zom, they did however climb P. 6175 m. by the straightforward south west flank above the Qualandar Gum glacier, giving the peak yet another name, Thui III.

While the botanists looked at the rich flora of the Thui An, and our liaison officer enjoyed a change of scene down in Sholton, Geoff and Des planned a bold attempt on Thui II (P. 6523 m.). Loaded down with a tunnel tent and food for seven days, they crossed over to the Qalandar Gum glacier (named after seven holy men alleged to have been lost there while attempting to cross the Thui An). Following its West side through an ice fall into an upper snow bowl they spent their second night On a col above the Shetor glacier, then continued over a subsidiary 20,000 foot peak, to a Camp at about 19,800 feet, below the south ridge of Thui II and well placed for a summit bid. Once again, how¬ever, Thui II was guarded by the weather. After fourteen fine days it suddenly changed, and a storm on 15 August marked the end of summer and the approach of winter, which we had been warned to expect about then. Feeling rather out on a limb, sitting out the snowstorm in their tunnel tent, there was no alternative to retreat, even though the weather cleared up again for a short time. The climbing season was over.

On the walk out down the Thui Gol, Geoff and I walked up onto the Ghalsapar glacier to examine the southern defenses of Thui Zom. A barren rocky bowl, hemmed in by steep walls, we felt glad that circumstances had thwarted our original plan to establish a Base Camp on that rubble covered glacier. Partly covered in cloud, the southern side of Thui Zom looked as im¬pregnable as the north. However, the fine looking surrounding peaks stirred our imaginations, and to the south the Mushk Bar glacier remains unexplored. The Thui Gol has much to offer .strong determined parties seeking alpine style climbing on a large scale. From our experiences the key lies in making full use of the summer months to ensure complete acclimatisation.